esaFX vs Valbury
Independent side-by-side on safety (scam-risk, regulation, reviews) and selection (costs, products, funding, who it's best for). We charge brokers nothing.
✦ AI comparison Premium · soon
An independent AI take on which of these fits you — from the data, not opinions for sale. Launching soon.
Safer pick Valbury leads on safety — winning 1 of 1
trust metrics (lower scam-risk, stronger regulation). Check the selection rows for the best fit.
Safety & Trust
Scam-risk scoreⓘ lower = safer
33
✓32
Verdict
Guarded
Guarded
Regulatedⓘ
Yes
Yes
Licenses
2
2
Tier-1 regulatorsⓘ
0
0
Trustpilot score
3.2
—
Reviews collected
1
—
Exit riskⓘ lower = safer
—
—
Known clonesⓘ
1
1
Regulator warnings
0
0
Cost & Accounts
Min deposit lower = easier to start
$10
—
Max leverage
1:200
1:500
Min spread (best acct)
from 1
✓from 0.28
Commission
✓$0.5
$1
Cost grade
—
—
Account types
3
3
Best for
Suits
Indonesian traders seeking a locally regulated broker, Low-budget retail traders (minimum deposit $10), Traders interested in Indonesian commodities like palm oil and coffee
Indonesian residents seeking a BAPPEBTI-regulated broker, Traders who prioritise high leverage with a maximum of 1:500, Those comfortable with a range of account types (Alpha, Sirius, Vega) without visible minimum deposit requirements
Not for
Traders requiring a wide range of instruments or major indices, Traders outside Indonesia (no international regulatory coverage), Traders seeking advanced platform features or algorithmic trading
Traders outside Indonesia (broker appears Indonesia-only), Those requiring detailed public information on spreads and commissions, Traders who need a broad selection of trading platforms and instruments
Products & Funding
Instruments
--
--
Deposit methods
—
--
Withdrawal
—
--
Execution
Speed
—
—
Slippage
—
—
Swap cost
—
—
Company
Founded
2025-02-18
2017-12-20
Headquarters
Indonesia
Indonesia
Employees
0
0
✓ = stronger value on that row · ● good · ● caution · ● weak · "—" = not yet collected. Independent scoring, never for sale.