esaFX vs Valbury
Independent side-by-side on safety (scam-risk, regulation, reviews) and selection (costs, products, funding, who it's best for). We charge brokers nothing.
✦ AI comparison Premium · soon
An independent AI take on which of these fits you — from the data, not opinions for sale. Launching soon.
Safer pick esaFX leads on safety — winning 1 of 1
trust metrics (lower scam-risk, stronger regulation). Check the selection rows for the best fit.
Safety & Trust
Scam-risk scoreⓘ lower = safer
✓33
36
Verdict
Guarded
Guarded
Regulatedⓘ
Yes
Yes
Licenses
2
2
Tier-1 regulatorsⓘ
0
0
Trustpilot score
3.2
—
Reviews collected
1
—
Exit riskⓘ lower = safer
—
—
Known clonesⓘ
1
1
Regulator warnings
0
0
Cost & Accounts
Min deposit lower = easier to start
$10
—
Max leverage
1:200
1:500
Min spread (best acct)
from 1
✓from 0.28
Commission
✓$0.5
$1
Cost grade
—
—
Account types
3
3
Best for
Suits
Indonesian traders seeking a locally regulated broker, Low-budget retail traders (minimum deposit $10), Traders interested in Indonesian commodities like palm oil and coffee
Indonesian residents seeking a BAPPEBTI-regulated broker, Traders comfortable with high leverage up to 1:500
Not for
Traders requiring a wide range of instruments or major indices, Traders outside Indonesia (no international regulatory coverage), Traders seeking advanced platform features or algorithmic trading
Traders requiring full transparency on trading costs and conditions, Beginners who need clear educational resources and demo accounts, International traders outside Indonesia
Products & Funding
Instruments
--
--
Deposit methods
—
--
Withdrawal
—
--
Execution
Speed
—
—
Slippage
—
—
Swap cost
—
—
Company
Founded
2025-02-18
2017-12-20
Headquarters
Indonesia
Indonesia
Employees
0
0
✓ = stronger value on that row · ● good · ● caution · ● weak · "—" = not yet collected. Independent scoring, never for sale.