BNY Mellon vs Robinhood
Independent side-by-side on safety (scam-risk, regulation, reviews) and selection (costs, products, funding, who it's best for). We charge brokers nothing.
✦ AI comparison Premium · soon
An independent AI take on which of these fits you — from the data, not opinions for sale. Launching soon.
These are different service types — a money-transfer service, bank or stockbroker isn’t a like-for-like alternative to a forex/CFD broker. Compare with that in mind.
Safer pick BNY Mellon leads on safety — winning 3 of 5
trust metrics (lower scam-risk, stronger regulation). Check the selection rows for the best fit.
Safety & Trust
Scam-risk scoreⓘ lower = safer
✓15
75
Verdict
Low risk
Severe
Regulatedⓘ
Yes
No
Licenses
✓2
0
Tier-1 regulatorsⓘ
✓2
0
Trustpilot score
2.3
✓3.8
Reviews collected
13
✓9802
Exit riskⓘ lower = safer
—
Elevated
Known clonesⓘ
0
0
Regulator warnings
0
0
Cost & Accounts
Min deposit lower = easier to start
—
—
Max leverage
—
—
Min spread (best acct)
—
—
Commission
—
—
Cost grade
—
—
Account types
0
0
Best for
Suits
—
Novice investors seeking a simple, mobile-first trading app, Users interested in commission-free stock, ETF, and crypto trading, Investors who value integrated banking and retirement features
Not for
Retail forex traders, Anyone needing responsive customer service, Traders who value transparent processes
Traders who require responsive, human customer support, Investors with large portfolios who need reliable margin and risk management, Users who prioritize regulatory oversight and strong investor protection
Products & Funding
Instruments
—
—
Deposit methods
—
—
Withdrawal
—
—
Execution
Speed
—
—
Slippage
—
—
Swap cost
—
—
Company
Founded
2018-11-27
2019-03-25
Headquarters
🇺🇸 United States
🇺🇸 United States
Employees
0
0
✓ = stronger value on that row · ● good · ● caution · ● weak · "—" = not yet collected. Independent scoring, never for sale.